Tuesday, September 25, 2007

ARMs - refi or not to refi?

I have been asked this question so many times over the past year that if I had a dollar for every time a client called up and asked me what they should do, I wouldn't even care about the housing slow down :-).

So, you have an ARM... should you refi? That depends. Just the answer you wanted to hear, right? Here are the things you need to consider:

1. How good is your rate?
2. How good is your credit compared to when you took out the mortgage?
3. How much time do you have left on your ARM before it adjusts?
4. By how much will it adjust (5% or 2%)?

And most importantly:

5. Can you sleep at night without having a fixed rate or what do you think the economy is going to do over the next few years?

If you answer the first 4 questions, you can use that information, along with what the rate you could get on a new fixed rate first mortgage, to determine at what point (given worst case ARM adjustments) you will break even with the new fixed rate mortgage. Since in most cases, the rate on the fixed rate mortgage is going to be higher than the ARM rate, this period of time can be somewhat substantial and thus you may want to wait to refinance the ARM. If you have a year or less, then it is probably time to seriously start looking at refinancing.

Now for question 5, if you can't sleep at night because rates have already gone up and you are worried they are going to go up further, then you need to refinance. Peace of mind trumps the numbers every day of the week. If a few more dollars a month is going to reduce your stress level, then it is worth it to refinance it.

The other part of question 5, is "what is the economy going to do". Let's put it this way, every economist is exactly right once in their life and they get their 15 minutes of fame. I am not an economist, but I feel like I keep my finger on the pulse of what the experts are saying and why. With that said, there are 3 possible scenarios that I feel are equally possible:

1. The housing/credit crunch sends the economy into a recession thus lowering the growth rate, inflation and long term interest rates. Therefore, mortgage rates will decrease.

2. The economy continues to grow and the fed over estimates the effect of the credit crunch and falls behind the curve of interest rate increases. This leads to higher inflation and thus higher long term interest rates. Mortgage rates go up substantially.

3. The economy falls into a recession due to the credit crunch, but due to high gas prices and lower worker productivity, inflation continues to increase. The fed will need to step in and control inflation first which means they will need to increase short term rates. Mortgage rates for both ARMS and fixed rate mortgages will go up substantially.

So, which of these scenarios is going to happen? The next 6 months should give us a much better idea. Are these scenarios an over simplification? Sure. Aren't those pretty much the scenarios for the economy at all times? Yes, but I haven't seen the opinions regarding what the fed should do this varied because economists have very different opinions as to which direction we are going to go.

If you would like to discuss your mortgage options, feel free to give me a call at 630 204-7486 or email me at scottv@promortgagepartners.com.

Friday, September 21, 2007

Good Explanation of the Credit Crunch

A friend of mine, Mike P., sent me this article that gives a good explanation of the credit crunch. Here is the link:

http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Investing/SuperModels/AreWeHeadedForAnEpicBearMarket.aspx?page=1

Here is the relatively short explanation of the credit crunch:

- mortgages used to be originated with banks own money. Now they are originated through warehouse lines and then packaged and sold to investors. Banks don't hold the debt; investors do through CDO's. Therefore, it is a less regulated environment.
- So, investors buy up these CDO's which are now assets which then can be used as leverage to buy more CDO's or for other investment. Basically, buying on margin, except to the extreme.
- When assets on margin lose value, they lose value more quickly just like they gain value more quickly when they are appreciating.
- Because of the all the foreclosures, the many CDO's are not being accepted as collateral for buying on margin.

So, what does this mean? Some investors and brokerage houses are losing their shirts. Also, this is reducing the liquidity in the economy. This is why the Fed reducing rates was so important.

While I don't have as pessimistic point of view as the expert stated in the article, I think there is a lot of truth to it. If you reduce the amount of money in the economy, there is less money to invest and therefore, less demand. That goes back to Econ 101 with supply and demand.

If you agree with his assumptions, this could lead to lower interest rates for mortgages in the future. The one thing he doesn't discuss is inflation. In my opinion we have two possible paths from here: An economy like about 4 years ago or an economy like the late 70's and early 80's. Neither is great, but I would take the first option over the second option any day of the week.

No, the credit crunch isn't over and the financial soap opera has just begun.

Wednesday, September 19, 2007

The Housing Crisis - this is normal

While I am not enjoying what is happening in real estate, I learned from an industry veteran that this has happened before. Bill Dallas predicted at least 18 months ago what is happening now was going to happen. Lets review the last couple of years and how we got to where we are today.

I got into the industry in 2002, when rates had already been coming down, but we hadn't yet seen the low in rates. As rates decreased, the mortgage business boomed. New businesses were created as a result and more people were employed by the industry then ever. As rates started to increase, mortgage companies/wholesalers had to find a way to continue to increase their growth and, at worst, hold onto the same amount of business. How do you do this in a market where refinances are being reduced? You expand your underwriting guidelines. This is done with great care, at first. As the market for refi's dries up, mortgage wholesalers get a little more desperate and loosen their standards a little more. Now these mortgages are the ones that are in trouble.

Add to that the mortgage brokers that specialized in selling the option ARM - you know the one... the negative amortization loan that starts out with the super loan payment only to bite you in the ass 3-5 years later when it recasts at a much higher rate with a bigger loan amount - you have a perfect storm of high foreclosures.

So... in summary, the industry saw tremendous growth through refi's; when the refi's dried up, wholesalers expanded their underwriting standards which lead to loans that should have never been made in the first place, which lead to a high foreclosure rate. So, now we have our current situation:

Lenders/wholesalers are tightening up their underwriting standards, but no just back to where they were before the refi boom. They are tightening up lending standards to where only allow good credit borrowers can obtain mortgages. This satisfies their investors who want to close their lines of credit which they use to fund the mortgages at closing.

So, basically, once everyone stops freaking out about all the foreclosures and they run their course, we will be able to get back to a normal lending environment. Now... how long will that take? Hopefully, only 6 months, but some are predicting it could take 2 to 3 years. It is a lot easier to predit what will happen, but it is a lot more difficult to predict the timing.

Monday, September 17, 2007

Will the Fed reduce the rate? Who cares?

OK, that may be a bit extreme, but I have received many phone calls from people who believe that if the fed reduces, then mortgage rates will go down. While this may happen, I think there is an equal chance that rates will go up. Here are my reasons:

1. The market has already factored in a rate cut of .25%. If the fed does this, then the market as a whole will have very little reaction to this.

2. If the market hasn't factored it in, the stock market will view this as a benefit for growth and the flow of money will be biased toward stocks. This will lead to a flow of money out of bonds which has a tendency to increase rates.

3. If the fed lowers, the fed may be viewed as having lost its focus on keeping inflation down, especially if they keep the risk of inflation in their statement. If the market thinks the fed has lost its focus on inflation, long term interest rates will increase.

I have heard the word "stagflation" used more in the last month then I have ever heard it before. For those that aren't familiar with the term, think of the late 70's. That was not a good time in our history and the fed had to take some drastic steps to get us out of it, including taking steps that intentionally led to increasing unemployment.

I am not trying to be the preacher of doom, but the situation for the fed is difficult. They may make a misstep or 2 along the way, but the fed will keep us generally on the right path to continued growth and stable inflation. But I digress a bit from my original point...

The fed decision tomorrow will not necessarily lead to lower rates for mortgages. Feel free to comment.

Welcome

Welcome to my new blog!! I will be discussing anything relating to the mortgage and real estate markets including the economy. I welcome open debate, but I will not allow personal attacks by or to anyone posting comments, whether they are agreeing or disagreeing with my opinions.